|
security
newsgroups
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||
access back end needs to be secureI intend to use an access file as the backend for my very data-driven vb.net
application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be access by a user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file so that no one can look at it thru the 'back door'? Thanks! Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also get in
through the back-end. First read the Access Security FAQ at http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to learn how to secure your database. If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone with the know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you just hard-code the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to find the string where you store it and then they could still get in. The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create a new group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that have a login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can prevent those users from having design permissions inside the database, but they'll still be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into a secured Access database). Show quote "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: > I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very data-driven vb.net > application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be access by a > user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file so that no > one can look at it thru the 'back door'? > > Thanks! > > > Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure?
"Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message Show quote news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also get in > through the back-end. > > First read the Access Security FAQ at > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to learn > how > to secure your database. > > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone with the > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you just > hard-code > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to find the > string > where you store it and then they could still get in. > > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create a new > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that have a > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can prevent > those > users from having design permissions inside the database, but they'll > still > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into a > secured > Access database). > > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: > >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very data-driven >> vb.net >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be access by >> a >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file so that >> no >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? >> >> Thanks! >> >> >> Jesse,
You can try MSDE or SQL Server Express (free download from MS). Immanuel Sibero Show quote "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message news:emWyVxafFHA.572@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... > Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure? > > > "Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" > <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message > news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... > > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also get in > > through the back-end. > > > > First read the Access Security FAQ at > > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to learn > > how > > to secure your database. > > > > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone with the > > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you just > > hard-code > > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to find the > > string > > where you store it and then they could still get in. > > > > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create a new > > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that have a > > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can prevent > > those > > users from having design permissions inside the database, but they'll > > still > > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into a > > secured > > Access database). > > > > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: > > > >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very data-driven > >> vb.net > >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be access by > >> a > >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file so that > >> no > >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? > >> > >> Thanks! > >> > >> > >> > > I thought you might say that. I tried MSDE (I'm developing for version 1.1
of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It made me wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i deploy it with my application!'. Show quote "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message news:eFURD3afFHA.2384@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... > > Jesse, > > You can try MSDE or SQL Server Express (free download from MS). > > Immanuel Sibero > > > > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message > news:emWyVxafFHA.572@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... >> Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure? >> >> >> "Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" >> <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message >> news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... >> > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also get in >> > through the back-end. >> > >> > First read the Access Security FAQ at >> > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to learn >> > how >> > to secure your database. >> > >> > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone with >> > the >> > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you just >> > hard-code >> > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to find the >> > string >> > where you store it and then they could still get in. >> > >> > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create a new >> > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that have a >> > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can prevent >> > those >> > users from having design permissions inside the database, but they'll >> > still >> > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into a >> > secured >> > Access database). >> > >> > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: >> > >> >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very data-driven >> >> vb.net >> >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be access > by >> >> a >> >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file so > that >> >> no >> >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? >> >> >> >> Thanks! >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> > > > of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It made Agreed. It's not the easiest. I think MS has a whole slew of informationme > wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i deploy > it with my application!'. (articles, documentation, etc.) on embedding MSDE/SQLExpress within your applicaton. Personally, I have installed MSDE manually (painfully, as you mentioned), but have never deployed it as part of an app. Immanuel Sibero Show quote "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message news:uV0PuDbfFHA.3612@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... > I thought you might say that. I tried MSDE (I'm developing for version 1.1 > of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It made me > wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i deploy > it with my application!'. > > > "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message > news:eFURD3afFHA.2384@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... > > > > Jesse, > > > > You can try MSDE or SQL Server Express (free download from MS). > > > > Immanuel Sibero > > > > > > > > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message > > news:emWyVxafFHA.572@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... > >> Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure? > >> > >> > >> "Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" > >> <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message > >> news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... > >> > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also get in > >> > through the back-end. > >> > > >> > First read the Access Security FAQ at > >> > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to learn > >> > how > >> > to secure your database. > >> > > >> > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone with > >> > the > >> > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you just > >> > hard-code > >> > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to find the > >> > string > >> > where you store it and then they could still get in. > >> > > >> > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create a new > >> > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that have a > >> > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can prevent > >> > those > >> > users from having design permissions inside the database, but they'll > >> > still > >> > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into a > >> > secured > >> > Access database). > >> > > >> > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: > >> > > >> >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very data-driven > >> >> vb.net > >> >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be access > > by > >> >> a > >> >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file so > > that > >> >> no > >> >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? > >> >> > >> >> Thanks! > >> >> > >> >> > >> >> > >> > >> > > > > > > MSDE seems like overkill anyway. The database size will not be large and
the sql stmnts will be relatively simple. Access is a good solution in all respects except one: it doesn't seem secure enough. There's got to be a way to store data outside my vb.net application, query that data from my app, write data to that data source from my app, and prevent hackers from accessing that data source directly. Show quote "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message news:O3AQWPbfFHA.3988@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl... > >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It made > me >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i > deploy >> it with my application!'. > > > Agreed. It's not the easiest. I think MS has a whole slew of information > (articles, documentation, etc.) on embedding MSDE/SQLExpress within your > applicaton. Personally, I have installed MSDE manually (painfully, as you > mentioned), but have never deployed it as part of an app. > > > Immanuel Sibero > > > > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message > news:uV0PuDbfFHA.3612@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... >> I thought you might say that. I tried MSDE (I'm developing for version > 1.1 >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It made > me >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i > deploy >> it with my application!'. >> >> >> "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message >> news:eFURD3afFHA.2384@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... >> > >> > Jesse, >> > >> > You can try MSDE or SQL Server Express (free download from MS). >> > >> > Immanuel Sibero >> > >> > >> > >> > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message >> > news:emWyVxafFHA.572@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... >> >> Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure? >> >> >> >> >> >> "Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" >> >> <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message >> >> news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... >> >> > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also get > in >> >> > through the back-end. >> >> > >> >> > First read the Access Security FAQ at >> >> > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to > learn >> >> > how >> >> > to secure your database. >> >> > >> >> > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone with >> >> > the >> >> > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you just >> >> > hard-code >> >> > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to find > the >> >> > string >> >> > where you store it and then they could still get in. >> >> > >> >> > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create a > new >> >> > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that have > a >> >> > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can >> >> > prevent >> >> > those >> >> > users from having design permissions inside the database, but >> >> > they'll >> >> > still >> >> > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into a >> >> > secured >> >> > Access database). >> >> > >> >> > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: >> >> > >> >> >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very > data-driven >> >> >> vb.net >> >> >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be > access >> > by >> >> >> a >> >> >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file >> >> >> so >> > that >> >> >> no >> >> >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? >> >> >> >> >> >> Thanks! >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> > >> > >> >> > > Jesse Aufiero wrote:
> MSDE seems like overkill anyway. The database size will not be large My standard advice... If the data needs to be secured form "users" then it> and the sql stmnts will be relatively simple. > > Access is a good solution in all respects except one: it doesn't seem > secure enough. There's got to be a way to store data outside my > vb.net application, query that data from my app, write data to that > data source from my app, and prevent hackers from accessing that data > source directly. should not be in an MDB file. Is this an app being run on a corporate network? If so SQL Server or MSDE is not "overkill". What are the data security needs concerning the users of the app? Whose data is it? -- I don't check the Email account attached to this message. Send instead to... RBrandt at Hunter dot com Jesse,
As long as you're considering standard commercial data format (i.e. mdb, dbf, etc.), there's probably always going to be a back way. Have you looked into encryption? I would think this might give you a whole host of possibilities that would suit your need. You could encrypt the data, the file, or both. Immanuel Sibero Show quote "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message news:eslkJabfFHA.3656@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl... > MSDE seems like overkill anyway. The database size will not be large and > the sql stmnts will be relatively simple. > > Access is a good solution in all respects except one: it doesn't seem secure > enough. There's got to be a way to store data outside my vb.net > application, query that data from my app, write data to that data source > from my app, and prevent hackers from accessing that data source directly. > > > "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message > news:O3AQWPbfFHA.3988@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl... > > > >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It made > > me > >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i > > deploy > >> it with my application!'. > > > > > > Agreed. It's not the easiest. I think MS has a whole slew of information > > (articles, documentation, etc.) on embedding MSDE/SQLExpress within your > > applicaton. Personally, I have installed MSDE manually (painfully, as you > > mentioned), but have never deployed it as part of an app. > > > > > > Immanuel Sibero > > > > > > > > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message > > news:uV0PuDbfFHA.3612@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... > >> I thought you might say that. I tried MSDE (I'm developing for version > > 1.1 > >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It made > > me > >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i > > deploy > >> it with my application!'. > >> > >> > >> "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message > >> news:eFURD3afFHA.2384@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... > >> > > >> > Jesse, > >> > > >> > You can try MSDE or SQL Server Express (free download from MS). > >> > > >> > Immanuel Sibero > >> > > >> > > >> > > >> > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message > >> > news:emWyVxafFHA.572@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... > >> >> Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure? > >> >> > >> >> > >> >> "Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" > >> >> <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in message > >> >> news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... > >> >> > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also get > > in > >> >> > through the back-end. > >> >> > > >> >> > First read the Access Security FAQ at > >> >> > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to > > learn > >> >> > how > >> >> > to secure your database. > >> >> > > >> >> > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone with > >> >> > the > >> >> > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you just > >> >> > hard-code > >> >> > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to find > > the > >> >> > string > >> >> > where you store it and then they could still get in. > >> >> > > >> >> > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create a > > new > >> >> > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that have > > a > >> >> > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can > >> >> > prevent > >> >> > those > >> >> > users from having design permissions inside the database, but > >> >> > they'll > >> >> > still > >> >> > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into a > >> >> > secured > >> >> > Access database). > >> >> > > >> >> > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: > >> >> > > >> >> >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very > > data-driven > >> >> >> vb.net > >> >> >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be > > access > >> > by > >> >> >> a > >> >> >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb file > >> >> >> so > >> > that > >> >> >> no > >> >> >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? > >> >> >> > >> >> >> Thanks! > >> >> >> > >> >> >> > >> >> >> > >> >> > >> >> > >> > > >> > > >> > >> > > > > > > Access encryption is only as secure as the database password, no? If the
database password is cracked, encryption doesn't help much, isn't that the way it works in Access? If you're referring to some other kinds of encryption, I'm all ears as to what they are. Are there methods outside of what Access provides that may help me here? Show quote "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message news:OogJE4bfFHA.1204@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... > Jesse, > > As long as you're considering standard commercial data format (i.e. mdb, > dbf, etc.), there's probably always going to be a back way. > Have you looked into encryption? I would think this might give you a whole > host of possibilities that would suit your need. You could encrypt the > data, > the file, or both. > > Immanuel Sibero > > > > > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message > news:eslkJabfFHA.3656@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl... >> MSDE seems like overkill anyway. The database size will not be large and >> the sql stmnts will be relatively simple. >> >> Access is a good solution in all respects except one: it doesn't seem > secure >> enough. There's got to be a way to store data outside my vb.net >> application, query that data from my app, write data to that data source >> from my app, and prevent hackers from accessing that data source >> directly. >> >> >> "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message >> news:O3AQWPbfFHA.3988@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl... >> > >> >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It > made >> > me >> >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i >> > deploy >> >> it with my application!'. >> > >> > >> > Agreed. It's not the easiest. I think MS has a whole slew of >> > information >> > (articles, documentation, etc.) on embedding MSDE/SQLExpress within >> > your >> > applicaton. Personally, I have installed MSDE manually (painfully, as > you >> > mentioned), but have never deployed it as part of an app. >> > >> > >> > Immanuel Sibero >> > >> > >> > >> > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message >> > news:uV0PuDbfFHA.3612@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... >> >> I thought you might say that. I tried MSDE (I'm developing for >> >> version >> > 1.1 >> >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It > made >> > me >> >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i >> > deploy >> >> it with my application!'. >> >> >> >> >> >> "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message >> >> news:eFURD3afFHA.2384@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... >> >> > >> >> > Jesse, >> >> > >> >> > You can try MSDE or SQL Server Express (free download from MS). >> >> > >> >> > Immanuel Sibero >> >> > >> >> > >> >> > >> >> > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message >> >> > news:emWyVxafFHA.572@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... >> >> >> Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure? >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> "Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" >> >> >> <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in >> >> >> message >> >> >> news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... >> >> >> > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also > get >> > in >> >> >> > through the back-end. >> >> >> > >> >> >> > First read the Access Security FAQ at >> >> >> > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp to >> > learn >> >> >> > how >> >> >> > to secure your database. >> >> >> > >> >> >> > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone > with >> >> >> > the >> >> >> > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you >> >> >> > just >> >> >> > hard-code >> >> >> > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to >> >> >> > find >> > the >> >> >> > string >> >> >> > where you store it and then they could still get in. >> >> >> > >> >> >> > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, create > a >> > new >> >> >> > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that > have >> > a >> >> >> > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can >> >> >> > prevent >> >> >> > those >> >> >> > users from having design permissions inside the database, but >> >> >> > they'll >> >> >> > still >> >> >> > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get into > a >> >> >> > secured >> >> >> > Access database). >> >> >> > >> >> >> > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: >> >> >> > >> >> >> >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very >> > data-driven >> >> >> >> vb.net >> >> >> >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be >> > access >> >> > by >> >> >> >> a >> >> >> >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb >> >> >> >> file >> >> >> >> so >> >> > that >> >> >> >> no >> >> >> >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> Thanks! >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> >> > >> >> > >> >> >> >> >> > >> > >> >> > > clarification - i meant to say: 'are there methods of encryption outside of
what Access offers that will allow me to better secure an Access back-end?' Show quote "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message news:%23L%23MRPdfFHA.1148@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... > Access encryption is only as secure as the database password, no? If the > database password is cracked, encryption doesn't help much, isn't that the > way it works in Access? > > If you're referring to some other kinds of encryption, I'm all ears as to > what they are. Are there methods outside of what Access provides that may > help me here? > > > "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message > news:OogJE4bfFHA.1204@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... >> Jesse, >> >> As long as you're considering standard commercial data format (i.e. mdb, >> dbf, etc.), there's probably always going to be a back way. >> Have you looked into encryption? I would think this might give you a >> whole >> host of possibilities that would suit your need. You could encrypt the >> data, >> the file, or both. >> >> Immanuel Sibero >> >> >> >> >> "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message >> news:eslkJabfFHA.3656@TK2MSFTNGP09.phx.gbl... >>> MSDE seems like overkill anyway. The database size will not be large >>> and >>> the sql stmnts will be relatively simple. >>> >>> Access is a good solution in all respects except one: it doesn't seem >> secure >>> enough. There's got to be a way to store data outside my vb.net >>> application, query that data from my app, write data to that data source >>> from my app, and prevent hackers from accessing that data source >>> directly. >>> >>> >>> "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message >>> news:O3AQWPbfFHA.3988@TK2MSFTNGP10.phx.gbl... >>> > >>> >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It >> made >>> > me >>> >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i >>> > deploy >>> >> it with my application!'. >>> > >>> > >>> > Agreed. It's not the easiest. I think MS has a whole slew of >>> > information >>> > (articles, documentation, etc.) on embedding MSDE/SQLExpress within >>> > your >>> > applicaton. Personally, I have installed MSDE manually (painfully, as >> you >>> > mentioned), but have never deployed it as part of an app. >>> > >>> > >>> > Immanuel Sibero >>> > >>> > >>> > >>> > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message >>> > news:uV0PuDbfFHA.3612@TK2MSFTNGP12.phx.gbl... >>> >> I thought you might say that. I tried MSDE (I'm developing for >>> >> version >>> > 1.1 >>> >> of the .Net frmwrk) and had a number of problems installing it. It >> made >>> > me >>> >> wonder 'if I can't install it on my own machine manually, how will i >>> > deploy >>> >> it with my application!'. >>> >> >>> >> >>> >> "Immanuel Sibero" <goah***@getlost.com> wrote in message >>> >> news:eFURD3afFHA.2384@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... >>> >> > >>> >> > Jesse, >>> >> > >>> >> > You can try MSDE or SQL Server Express (free download from MS). >>> >> > >>> >> > Immanuel Sibero >>> >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > >>> >> > "Jesse Aufiero" <jaufi***@moaboil.com> wrote in message >>> >> > news:emWyVxafFHA.572@TK2MSFTNGP15.phx.gbl... >>> >> >> Can you suggest an alternative to Access that is more secure? >>> >> >> >>> >> >> >>> >> >> "Phillip (formerly "theriaup")" >>> >> >> <Phillipformerlytheri***@discussions.microsoft.com> wrote in >>> >> >> message >>> >> >> news:30C98C14-E877-447E-84AF-43F913FEA695@microsoft.com... >>> >> >> > Generally, if you can get in through the front-end you can also >> get >>> > in >>> >> >> > through the back-end. >>> >> >> > >>> >> >> > First read the Access Security FAQ at >>> >> >> > http://support.microsoft.com/support/access/content/secfaq.asp >>> >> >> > to >>> > learn >>> >> >> > how >>> >> >> > to secure your database. >>> >> >> > >>> >> >> > If you give users a login/password to access the system, anyone >> with >>> >> >> > the >>> >> >> > know-how could log into the Access database directly. If you >>> >> >> > just >>> >> >> > hard-code >>> >> >> > the login/password into the application, it can be cracked to >>> >> >> > find >>> > the >>> >> >> > string >>> >> >> > where you store it and then they could still get in. >>> >> >> > >>> >> >> > The best solution would be to follow the steps in the FAQ, >>> >> >> > create >> a >>> > new >>> >> >> > group with minimal rights, and create users for that group that >> have >>> > a >>> >> >> > login/password you can give out to whoever needs it. You can >>> >> >> > prevent >>> >> >> > those >>> >> >> > users from having design permissions inside the database, but >>> >> >> > they'll >>> >> >> > still >>> >> >> > be able to see the data (again, only if they know how to get >>> >> >> > into >> a >>> >> >> > secured >>> >> >> > Access database). >>> >> >> > >>> >> >> > "Jesse Aufiero" wrote: >>> >> >> > >>> >> >> >> I intend to use an access file as the backend for my very >>> > data-driven >>> >> >> >> vb.net >>> >> >> >> application. I need to secure this file so that it can only be >>> > access >>> >> > by >>> >> >> >> a >>> >> >> >> user through the vb.net front end. How can I secure the mdb >>> >> >> >> file >>> >> >> >> so >>> >> > that >>> >> >> >> no >>> >> >> >> one can look at it thru the 'back door'? >>> >> >> >> >>> >> >> >> Thanks! >>> >> >> >> >>> >> >> >> >>> >> >> >> >>> >> >> >>> >> >> >>> >> > >>> >> > >>> >> >>> >> >>> > >>> > >>> >>> >> >> > > He is saying that you could encrypt the data using your own additional
application code, before you stored it in the Access database. Then, even if someone cracked the Access database, they would only get your encrypted data - not your unencrypted data. This could work quite well if you chose an appropriate cipher & ensured that the cipher key was not readily discernable (eg. as a text string within the database). HTH, TC Thanks for input thus far. I appreciate the time.
I see. In my case, I would want to encrypt every column of every table... which would probably slow down and complicate the qry stmnts i would be issuing from the front-end, no? Maybe there is a way to encrypt the entire mdb file with a key that only my application front-end (and myself - of course) know. Then, at start up, my application could decrypt the entire file - incurring the penalty once, up front; and my application would not need any further 'decryption code' as it works with (querys/inserts into) the database. And I'm not talking about Access' 'database-level password' here because from what I understand that password can be hacked even when the database is encrypted, right? Show quote "TC" <aatcbbtcc***@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:1120222948.860458.62550@o13g2000cwo.googlegroups.com... > He is saying that you could encrypt the data using your own additional > application code, before you stored it in the Access database. Then, > even if someone cracked the Access database, they would only get your > encrypted data - not your unencrypted data. > > This could work quite well if you chose an appropriate cipher & ensured > that the cipher key was not readily discernable (eg. as a text string > within the database). > > HTH, > TC > Jesse Aufiero wrote:
> Thanks for input thus far. I appreciate the time. It would not necessarily complicate it all that much. For example,> > I see. In my case, I would want to encrypt every column of every table... > which would probably slow down and complicate the qry stmnts i would be > issuing from the front-end, no? instead of writing: select person_name from tblPersonDetails where person_id = 45 you might write: select decrypt(person_name) from tblPersonDetails where decrypt(person_id) = 45 But on reflection, it would probably defeat a lot of the query optimization that the database does "behind the scenes". You'd have to test it very carefully, to see whether you got adequate performance, especially as it scaled with more records. > Maybe there is a way to encrypt the entire mdb file with a key that only my Sure you could do that. And it would be the simplest method, because> application front-end (and myself - of course) know. Then, at start up, my > application could decrypt the entire file - incurring the penalty once, up > front; and my application would not need any further 'decryption code' as it > works with (querys/inserts into) the database. you would not need any changes to the existing database queries or code. But now there's something I don't understand - perhaps because I haven't followed the start of this thread. Does the end-user have access to the PC where the database is? If yes, then, the "decrypt once" technique does not help; he just copies the /decrypted/ database. If no (he doesn't have access to the PC), then, he can not copy the database anyway, no? > And I'm not talking about The database password, and even (unfortunately) the user level pwds can> Access' 'database-level password' here because from what I understand that > password can be hacked even when the database is encrypted, right? both be hacked using various products. This is nothing to do with the encryption (or non-encryption) of the database file. HTH, TC The database would be stored on the users computer. But I don't want the
user to be able to hack their way in and see the data. Only my application's front-end (coded in .Net) should be able to access the data. Is their no way to make the mdb invulnerable to hacks? Or should they change this newsgroup's name to microsoft.public.access.lackofsecurity ;-) Show quote "TC" <aatcbbtcc***@yahoo.com> wrote in message news:1120276558.127244.19860@z14g2000cwz.googlegroups.com... > > Jesse Aufiero wrote: >> Thanks for input thus far. I appreciate the time. >> >> I see. In my case, I would want to encrypt every column of every >> table... >> which would probably slow down and complicate the qry stmnts i would be >> issuing from the front-end, no? > > > It would not necessarily complicate it all that much. For example, > instead of writing: > > select person_name > from tblPersonDetails > where person_id = 45 > > you might write: > > select decrypt(person_name) > from tblPersonDetails > where decrypt(person_id) = 45 > > But on reflection, it would probably defeat a lot of the query > optimization that the database does "behind the scenes". You'd have to > test it very carefully, to see whether you got adequate performance, > especially as it scaled with more records. > > >> Maybe there is a way to encrypt the entire mdb file with a key that only >> my >> application front-end (and myself - of course) know. Then, at start up, >> my >> application could decrypt the entire file - incurring the penalty once, >> up >> front; and my application would not need any further 'decryption code' as >> it >> works with (querys/inserts into) the database. > > Sure you could do that. And it would be the simplest method, because > you would not need any changes to the existing database queries or > code. But now there's something I don't understand - perhaps because I > haven't followed the start of this thread. Does the end-user have > access to the PC where the database is? If yes, then, the "decrypt > once" technique does not help; he just copies the /decrypted/ database. > If no (he doesn't have access to the PC), then, he can not copy the > database anyway, no? > > >> And I'm not talking about >> Access' 'database-level password' here because from what I understand >> that >> password can be hacked even when the database is encrypted, right? > > The database password, and even (unfortunately) the user level pwds can > both be hacked using various products. This is nothing to do with the > encryption (or non-encryption) of the database file. > > HTH, > TC > Jesse Aufiero wrote:
> The database would be stored on the users computer. But I don't want No. Data that needs to be protected from *users* does not belong in an MDB> the user to be able to hack their way in and see the data. Only my > application's front-end (coded in .Net) should be able to access the > data. > > Is their no way to make the mdb invulnerable to hacks? Or should they > change this newsgroup's name to > microsoft.public.access.lackofsecurity ;-) file. You can do many things to erect barriers for unsophisticated users, but anyone with a few bucks who knows how to use Google can get into an MDB file. You could change the extension so it's not "mdb" and put it into a non-obvious location on the drive and the user would likely never even know where to look; again, depending on his level of PC knowledge. -- I don't check the Email account attached to this message. Send instead to... RBrandt at Hunter dot com Rick - you make a good suggestion. Thanks.
Show quote "Rick Brandt" <rickbran***@hotmail.com> wrote in message news:eMbze.1578$Ae.94@newssvr12.news.prodigy.com... > Jesse Aufiero wrote: >> The database would be stored on the users computer. But I don't want >> the user to be able to hack their way in and see the data. Only my >> application's front-end (coded in .Net) should be able to access the >> data. >> >> Is their no way to make the mdb invulnerable to hacks? Or should they >> change this newsgroup's name to >> microsoft.public.access.lackofsecurity ;-) > > No. Data that needs to be protected from *users* does not belong in an > MDB > file. You can do many things to erect barriers for unsophisticated users, > but anyone with a few bucks who knows how to use Google can get into an > MDB > file. > > You could change the extension so it's not "mdb" and put it into a > non-obvious location on the drive and the user would likely never even > know > where to look; again, depending on his level of PC knowledge. > > -- > I don't check the Email account attached > to this message. Send instead to... > RBrandt at Hunter dot com > > It depends what you mean by "invulnerable". Do you mean, for example,
invulnerable to someone who has access to a huge distributed computing network, and can brute-force 56-bit keys in a few hours? Security means nothing unless you say what threat level you need to secure against. If you need to secure against the average user, Access might do. If you need to secure against the NSA, Access probably would not do. HTH, TC |
|||||||||||||||||||||||